Request a Paid, Substantive Strategy Session with a New York Ethics Lawyer

A Strategy Session with David A. Lewis Law is a confidential legal working session, conducted by phone, for up to an hour. It gives you my assessment of the New York ethics or admission issue you are facing and practical advice on how to proceed. The Session may be all that is needed.

I review each request personally to determine whether a Strategy Session may be appropriate. If it is, scope, fee, and scheduling can be discussed before you decide whether to proceed. If timing is a concern, you may also call (212) 951-1819. Submitting the form or contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship.

When a grievance inquiry, Character and Fitness issue, NYBOLE matter, Court of Appeals waiver issue, application amendment, law school application disclosure, self-reporting question, or professional responsibility issue may affect admission, licensure, reputation, or professional standing, the next step should be handled with judgment. The fee is for legal judgment before a response, disclosure, amendment, petition, self-report, or professional decision creates a record.

I represent lawyers, law students, law school applicants, bar applicants, law firms, and professionals; I generally do not represent people bringing complaints against lawyers, and I do not handle plaintiff legal malpractice claims.

Request a Strategy Session

A paid telephone Session, personally conducted by David A. Lewis, for up to an hour. This form requests consideration; scope, fee and scheduling can be discussed before you decide whether to proceed.

Fields marked * are required

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Location

What area(s) do you need help with?*
Please check at least one.
A sentence or two is enough.

Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

Confirmation*
The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

What You Should Expect to Leave With

You should leave with a clearer understanding of the issue, the main risks, the available options, and the practical next step.

For a lawyer answering an Attorney Grievance Committee inquiry, that means the rules the Committee is likely evaluating, the documents that define the record, the deadline and whether to seek more time, and the framework for the written response.

For an applicant deciding whether to disclose or amend, it means a view on whether the matter falls within the question as worded, what the records show, how the answer should be framed, and the order in which the steps should be taken.

For an attorney whose admission-on-motion application has raised a practice-credit question, it means a view on whether the work counts under Section 520.10, whether the record supports a Section 520.14 petition and which rule problem it must address, and how the answer to the Appellate Division and any petition should be sequenced so the two do not contradict each other.

For an applicant with a NYBOLE inquiry and a held Character and Fitness file, it means a view on what the Board and the Committee are each evaluating, the order in which the two responses are due, whether to ask either for more time, and how what is said to the Board and what is said to the Committee are kept consistent.

For a lawyer, law firm, or in-house counsel deciding whether to rely on a conflict waiver, withdraw from a matter, report conduct, or respond to a lawyer’s departure, it means a view on the duties that apply, what should be documented, and the professional consequences of the proposed course.

How the Session Works

In most matters, what happened is only part of the problem. The issue you are worried about is not always the issue the decision maker will care about most. The Session works through the actual issue, the posture and the deadline, what the record already contains, and the rules and institutional concerns in play. It weighs the risks the next response itself can create and the available options: respond, amend, disclose, correct, seek more time, prepare a petition, self-report, or wait. The same facts may call for different treatment before a law school, a Character and Fitness committee, NYBOLE, an Attorney Grievance Committee, or the Court of Appeals. Some matters require action; others, restraint.

Session Details

Format. By phone, for up to an hour. The advice is given during the call; no written opinion or summary is included. Where it would help, I read a few pages in advance. Any material pre-session document review is separately defined and agreed upon in advance.

Scope. Drafting, document revision, approval of a finished submission, broader factual development, or full representation requires a separate written engagement unless expressly included.

Who the client is. The person receiving the legal advice is the client unless a written agreement provides otherwise. If you are reading for someone else, a family member, a colleague, or a lawyer in your firm, you may arrange the Session or pay for the work, and you may take part only with that client’s authorization, after confidentiality and privilege questions are addressed.

Focus. The Session focuses on the issues that appear most important, based on the information provided, the documents available, and the time reasonably available. Where the facts do not yet support a recommendation, I identify what is missing and why it matters.

Lawyers with a firm or employer. A lawyer may request a Session individually; whether and when to involve a firm, a supervising lawyer, or an employer is part of what the Session addresses.

Requesting a Session. Use the request form or call (212) 951-1819. Requesting a Session does not commit you to further representation. A Strategy Session is paid legal work, not a sales call. I review each request personally to determine whether a Session may be appropriate. If it is, scope, fee, and scheduling can be discussed before you decide whether to proceed. The Session may be all that is needed.

Who Conducts the Session

The lawyer who conducts the Strategy Session is the same lawyer who evaluates the response, advises on risk, and handles any continued engagement if representation follows. That is always me. I do not assign client matters to associates or route sensitive client materials through a volume intake model. This work is the whole of my practice.

Discretion is built into how I work. So is the ability to discuss difficult facts directly and carefully.

David A. Lewis

Former Chair, New York City Bar Association Professional Responsibility Committee.

Former member, New York State Bar Association Committee on Standards of Attorney Conduct.

Former adjunct professor of legal ethics and professional responsibility, Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law.

Rated AV Preeminent by Martindale-Hubbell for professional ability and ethical standards.

Twelve years as an ethics attorney or general counsel to private law firms before founding the practice in 2016.

More than 1,000 bar applicants advised in admission-related matters over more than twenty years.

More than twenty years focused on legal ethics, bar admission, attorney discipline, Court of Appeals waiver petitions, NYBOLE, Character and Fitness, and professional responsibility matters.

Client Feedback

David was an incredible source of guidance and support throughout my Character and Fitness process for bar admission. I came to him feeling extremely anxious after making a poor decision at a previous place of employment, but he never once made me feel judged or ashamed. Instead, he clearly explained the process, helped me understand my options, and was honest with me every step of the way.

From a client’s account of a Character and Fitness matter, published with the client’s consent. The full account is on the Client Feedback page.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Who Should Request a Strategy Session

Lawyers Facing Attorney Grievance or Professional Conduct Issues.

New York lawyers who have received an Attorney Grievance Committee inquiry, request for written response, request for information, disciplinary complaint, or other professional responsibility communication.

Bar Applicants, Law Students, and Law School Applicants.

Applicants and students facing Character and Fitness issues, prior omissions, application amendments, academic discipline disclosures, criminal history disclosures, financial disclosures, employment history issues, substance-related disclosures, or other admission-related concerns, including applicants deciding, before a law school application is submitted, whether academic discipline or an arrest must be disclosed and how.

NYBOLE Matters.

Applicants facing Notices of Charges or other matters before the New York State Board of Law Examiners.

Waiver of Strict Compliance and Admission Eligibility Matters.

Law graduates, attorneys, admission-on-motion applicants, foreign-trained lawyers, and multijurisdictional practitioners facing Court of Appeals waiver issues, admission timing problems, expired or expiring UBE score concerns, NYLE timing issues, or practice-time eligibility questions.

More Than One of These at Once.

A NYBOLE inquiry and a held Character and Fitness file, an amendment question and a scheduled interview, or a grievance inquiry and a question whether a criminal disposition must be reported, are addressed together, because each response may later be read alongside the other.

Reciprocal Discipline, Self-Reporting, and Multijurisdiction Issues.

Lawyers facing disclosure complications, reciprocal discipline exposure, self-reporting questions, inconsistent records across jurisdictions, or professional standing issues involving more than one jurisdiction.

Law Firms and In-House Counsel.

Law firms, partners, employers, and in-house counsel seeking guidance on registration, legal ethics, internal professional responsibility issues, conflicts, confidentiality, supervision, withdrawal, reporting obligations, lawyer departures, client duties, or recurring professional responsibility questions.

Anyone facing one of these matters may request a Strategy Session.

For Referring Counsel

Many matters arrive by referral, from criminal and white-collar defense counsel, employment and malpractice counsel, managing partners, professors, law school administrators, and former clients and their families.

A referred matter begins the same way as any other: with a conflict check and a paid, confidential Strategy Session. The client referred receives the same direct, personal handling as every other client, and I am glad to confer with referring counsel to the extent the client authorizes. Referring counsel may also call (212) 951-1819.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Session may be all that is needed. An applicant deciding whether to amend a law school or bar application, for example, can use the Session to settle whether the record requires a correction, what it must cover, and how the earlier answer should be accounted for. Whether to proceed on your own afterward is your decision. Counsel matters more where the records are inconsistent, the matter involves criminal history or academic discipline, a committee has already asked, or a deadline is close.

The Strategy Session involves substantive legal work; it is not a sales call or an intake call. If a Session may be appropriate, scope, fee, and scheduling can be discussed before you decide whether to proceed.

The advice is given during the call; no written opinion or summary is included. Drafting, revising, or approving a finished document requires a separate written engagement unless expressly included. If the matter calls for additional document review, factual development, or representation beyond the Session, that will be discussed.

If continued representation is appropriate, I discuss the proposed scope, fee structure, and next procedural steps, governed by a written engagement letter. Whether or not representation follows, the purpose of the Session is to reach a sound strategic conclusion.

Gather the key documents, note any deadline, and prepare a short chronology: what happened, what was disclosed or omitted, and what has happened since. For a disclosure question, the key documents are the application question itself, the school or court paperwork, and any answer already given. If a court record was sealed and you do not have it, say so in the form; whether and how it can be obtained is one of the questions the Session addresses, and the request need not wait for the document. For a grievance inquiry, the key documents are the Committee’s letter, the complaint, and the file.

Be candid about the facts. Embarrassment and blame have no place in the Session. Its purpose is to understand the record clearly enough to assess risk and decide the next step.

Yes. Information shared in a Strategy Session to seek legal advice is treated as confidential under the professional duties that apply to prospective clients.

I handle information from prospective clients in accordance with Rule 1.18 of the New York Rules of Professional Conduct, even if we do not proceed with a Session. Professional confidentiality and attorney-client privilege are different; whether a particular communication is privileged depends on the circumstances.

If timing is a concern, you may also call (212) 951-1819. Whether to seek more time from the decision maker is one of the options a Session weighs.

Yes, if the client authorizes it. The attorney, applicant, or candidate remains the client. If a parent or family member pays the fee, the applicant remains the client and controls the representation and the decisions that must be made. If a family member or third party will participate, that should be discussed in advance because confidentiality and privilege issues may need to be addressed.

That is one of the first questions the Session addresses. You remain the client. Whether the firm should be told, whether its general counsel or management should participate, and on what terms, are decided in advance, because confidentiality, privilege, supervision, and the firm’s own records may be affected. If a firm arranges the Session or pays for the work, the lawyer receiving the legal advice is the client unless a written agreement provides otherwise, and the firm takes part only with that lawyer’s authorization.

Begin With a Strategy Session

The Session is paid, confidential, and conducted by phone, and I conduct it personally.